Introspection

also Self-Examination


Understanding yourself by analyzing your own ideas, emotions, and traits, which is hard mainly because you must untangle decades of poorly-learned, uncriticized ideas.

Introspection is the activity of understanding yourself by analyzing your own ideas, emotions, and character traits. CF reframes it sharply: introspection is not discovering some fixed inner nature that is simply hard to observe — it is a learning process. People struggle with it because they skipped steps when forming many of their ideas, reaching conclusions about how to act and what to value without ever understanding or criticizing them. Such ideas are often lazy assumptions and unexamined errors that only seemed to work due to bias rather than any objective check.

On CF’s analysis, the real difficulty is not that ideas are subconscious or that some special introspective method is missing — ordinary thinking suffices. The difficulty is scale: you have built up complex confusions over decades, and untangling that mess is daunting, so most people never seriously start. This parallels overreaching: both demand pausing, clearing the schedule, and rebuilding from basics.

A central application is diagnosing procrastination and other internal conflicts. If part of you resists an activity, that resistance is a substantive criticism you have not refuted — not mere laziness to override. Introspection surfaces and respects that objection. It is also the tool for articulating intuitions: gathering data points by posing scenarios and noting your responses, rather than suppressing the intuition.

CF stresses building the skill incrementally. Since reading the contents of your own mind is harder than reading a book, you should first get good at analyzing sentences, arguments, and other people’s emotions, starting with easy cases before tackling your own emotions.


See also

Referenced by


Sources

  1. Introspection, Overreaching and Emotions Primary criticalfallibilism.com
  2. Don't Suppress Your Intuition Supporting criticalfallibilism.com
  3. Procrastination Supporting criticalfallibilism.com
/term/introspection/