Deliberate Relearning

also Habit change · Replacing automatized knowledge

Coined · Elliot Temple

The intentional practice of overwriting an automatized false belief or bad habit with a better one, which requires first consciously understanding both options and genuinely agreeing the replacement is better.

Deliberate relearning is CF’s account of how to fix knowledge that has already been wrongly automatized. Because practice hands a skill to the subconscious for cheap, automatic execution (automatization), a mistake practiced into a habit becomes stable and resistant to conscious correction — the same durability that makes good habits reliable also entrenches bad ones (the bias-automatization problem). Simply learning a better idea consciously is often not enough; the old automatization keeps firing. Relearning means going back and intentionally practicing the replacement, similar to how the skill was first acquired.

CF’s specific claim is that ease of relearning is diagnostic. Some habits change in minutes (remapping game keys, retraining which finger types a letter); when a habit resists change far more than that, you usually lack a clear conscious grasp of what the old knowledge is, what the new knowledge is, and why the new is better — or you have an unresolved internal disagreement. Relearning is much easier once you are convinced the change is strictly better rather than a tradeoff with pros and cons, because a lingering intuitive objection keeps the subconscious from cooperating (subconscious-conscious alignment).

This is why CF urges critical thinking before practicing: relearning is the costly remedy, so it is better to error-check ideas first. But it rejects perfectionism — you will inevitably automatize some mistakes, and that is fine, because automatizations, intuitions and the subconscious can be revisited and changed later. Relearning is distinct from a momentary behavioral override, which fights a habit in the moment without actually replacing it.


See also

Referenced by


Sources

  1. Automatized Knowledge Can Resist Bias Primary criticalfallibilism.com
  2. Learning, Habits and Automation Supporting criticalfallibilism.com
/term/deliberate-relearning/